:::
Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Responsible Project Management: beyond the triple constraints

Rocio Alvarez Tinoco, Carlos Eduardo Yamasaki Sato, Rumy Hasan

Abstract


In this theoretical paper, we propose the concept of Responsible Project Management drawing upon perspectives from responsible innovation, accountability and sustainability in project environments, especially those of megaprojects, addressing their long-term impact, far beyond the traditional notion of project success on the triple constraints of time, cost and adherence to specifications. Megaprojects as multibillion dollar projects (e.g., the Channel Tunnel, organisation of London Olympics 2012 and the construction of Heathrow Airport Terminal 5) are very important parts of infrastructure in developed and developing countries, where traditional project management analysis focuses on the implementation or execution process (i.e. planning and control) usually incurring delays, cost overrun and financial risk. However, this analysis requires further understanding regarding their complexity and their effects on environment and society as a whole. Furthermore, management of megaprojects as a professional practice lacks a framework to provide lessons to support the improvement of decision-making process for the future generation of infrastructure for development, which increasingly has to be built up under sustainability and accountability premises. This paper proposes an integrative framework based on four dimensions of responsible innovation, four instruments of accountability and six principles addressing sustainability that help to define and implement megaprojects, aiming at an inclusive approach – to better inform practitioners, policy makers, academics, and the wider society - when decisions about building megaprojects are taken. This framework might help also to analyse megaprojects in order to extract lessons that might be useful in the controversial arena of infrastructure development.


Keywords


Responsible Project Management; Project Management; Responsible Innovation; Irresponsible Innovation; Social Demands; Megaprojects.

References


BARLOW, J. (2000) Innovation and Learning in Complex Offshore Construction Projects. Research Policy, 29, 973-989.

BREDILLET, C. N. (2005) Reconciling uncertainty and responsibility in the management of projects. Project management Journal, September, 3.

BRUZELIUS, N., FLYVBJERG, B. & ROTHENGATTER, W. (1998) 'Big Decisions, Big Risks: Improving Accountability in Mega Projects. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 64, 423-440.

CHAREST, P. (1995) Aboriginal Alternatives to Megaprojects and their Environmental and Social Impacts. Impact Assessment, 13, 371-386.

DAVIES, A., GANN, D. & DOUGLAS, T. (2009) Innovation in Megaprojects: Systems Integration at London Heathrow Terminal 5. California Management Review, 51, 101-125.

DAVIES, A. & HOBDAY, M. (2005) The business of projects. Managing innovation in complex products and systems, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

DAVIES, A. & MACKENZIE, I. (2014) Project complexity and systems integration: Constructing the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics Games. International Journal of Project Management, 32, 773-790.

DE SCHEPPER, S., DOOMS, M. & HAEZENDONCK, E. (2014) Stakeholders dynamics and responsibilities in PublicPrivate Partnerships: A mixed experience. International Journal of Project Management, 1210-1222.

DENG, Y. & POON, S. W. (2013) Meeting sustainability challenges of mega-events flagships. Engineering Construction and Architectural Management, 20, 46-62.

EDUM-FOTWE, F. T. & PRICE, A. D. F. (2009) A social ontology for aqppraissing sustainability of construction projects and development. International Journal of Project Management, 27, 313-322.

FISHER, E. & RIP, A. (2013) Responsible innovation: Multi-level dynamics and soft intervention practices. IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Responsible innovation: Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation in society. Chichester, West Sussex. UK, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

FLYVBJERG, B., BRUZELIUS, N. & ROTHENGATTER, W. (2013) Megaprojects and risk. An anatomy of ambition, Cambridge.

GAAFAR, H. K. & PERRY, J. G. (1998) Limitation of design liability for contractors International Journal of Project Management, 17, 301-308.

GAREIS, R., HUEUMANN, M. & MARTINUZZI, A. (2011) What project management learn from considering sustainable principles? Project Perspective, XXXIII, 60-65.

GELLERT, P. K. & LYNCH, B. D. (2003) Mega-Projects as Displacements. International Social Science Journal,, 55, 15-25.

GIL, N., MIOZZO, M. & MASSINI, S. (2012) The Innovation Potential of New Infrastructure Development: An Empirical Study of Heathrow Airport's T5 Project. Research Policy, 41, 452-466.

GILBERT, R., STEVENSON, D., GIRARDET, H. & STERN, R. (1996) Making cities work: The role of local authorities in the urban environment, Earthscan Publications Ltd.

HOBDAY, M. (1998) Product complexity, innovation and industrial organisation. Research Policy, 26, 689-710.

KLAKEGG, O. J. (2009) Pursuing relevance and sustainability. Improvement strategies for major public projects. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 2, 499-518.

LASZLO, E. (1991) Responsible (project) management in an unstable world. International Journal of Project Management, 9, 68-70.

LÖVRAND, E., PIELKE, R. & BECK, S. (2011) A democracy paradox in studies of science and innovation. Science, Technology and Human Values, 36, 474-496.

MACNAGHTEN, P., OWEN, R., STILGOE, J., WYNNE, B., AZEVEDO, A., DE CAMPOS, A., CHILVERS, J., DAGNINO, R., G. DI GIULIO, G., FROW, E., GARVEY, B., GROVES, C., HARTLEY, S., KNOBEL, M., KOBAYASHI, E., LEHTONEN, M., LEZAUN, J., MELLO, L., MONTEIRO, M., PAMPLONA DA COSTA, J., RIGOLIN, C., RONDANI, B., STAYKOVA, M., TADDEI, R., TILL, C., TYFIELD, D., WILFORD, S. & VELHO, L. (2014) Responsible innovation across borders: tensions, paradoxes and possibilities. Journal of Responsible Innovation, 1, 191-199.

MARTENS, M. (2006) Sustainability, science or fiction. Sustainability: Science, Practice & Policy, 2, 36-41.

MOLLE, F. & FLOCH, P. (2008) Megaprojects and Social and Environmental Changes: The Case of the Thai "Water Grid". Ambio: A Journal of the Human Environment, 37, 199-204.

MUELLER, R., PEMSEL, S. & SHAO, J. (2014) Organizational enablers for governance and governmentality of projects: A literature review. International Journal of Project Management, 32, 1309-1320.

MUFF, K. (2013) Developing globally responsible leaders in business schools. The Journal of Management Development, 32, 487-507.

MURAKAMI, Y., KOBAYASHI, T., OMORI, T., OKUYAMA, H., YOSHIZAWA, G., FUKUSHIMA, K. & HAMADA, S. (2013) Expanding the range of participants and a new role for experts. Interactions between Science, Technology and Society. Report in R&D Focus Area: Science Technology and Humanity. Tokyo, Research Institute of Science and Technology for Society (RISTEX). Japan Science and Technology Agency (JST).

OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (2013a) Responsible innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation in society, Chichester, West Sussex. UK, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

OWEN, R., STILGOE, J., MACNAGHTEN, P., GORMAN, M., FISHER, E. & GUSTON, D. (2013b) A framework for responsible innovation. IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Respponsible innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation in society. First ed. Chichester, West Sussex. UK, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

PARKHILL, K., PIDGEON, N., CORNER, A. & VAQUGHAN, N. (2013) Deliberation and responsible innovation: A geoingineering case study. IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Responsible Innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and Innovation in society. First ed. United Kingdom, John Wiley & Sons, LTD.

PLANKO, J. & SILVIUS, G. (2012) Sustainability on business. IN SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R., PLANKO, J., VAN DEN BRINK, J. & KÖLHER, A. (Eds.) Sustainability in Project Management. Farnham, Surrey. england, Gower Publishing.

PMBOK (2013) A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, Newton Square, PA.

ROBINSON, J. (2004) Squaring the circle? Some thoughts on the idea of sustainable development. Ecological economics, 48, 369-384.

ROGERS-HAYDEN, T. & PIDGEON, N. (2007) Moving engagement "upstream"? Nanotechnologies and the Royal Society and Royal Academy of Engineering's inquiry. Public Understanding of Sience, 76, 1222-1239.

ROMZEK, B. S. & DUBNICK, M. J. (1987) Accountability in the Public Sector: Lessons from the Challenger Tragedy. Public Administration Review, 47, 227-238.

ROTHENGATTER, W. (2008) Innovations in the Planning of Mega-Projects. IN PRIEMUS, H., FLYVBJERG, B. & VAN WEE, B. (Eds.) Decision-Making on Mega-Projects: Cost-Benefit Analysis Planning and Innovation. Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, Edward Elgar Publishing.

RUSSELL, J. (2008) Corporate Social Responsibility: What it means for the project manager. PMI Europe Congress. Zurich.

SCHIPPER, R. & SILVIUS, G. (2013) Taking resposibility. Project. The voice of Project Management, 257, 24-27.

SCHIPPER, R., SILVIUS, G. & VAN DER BRINK, J. (2012) Reflection and conclusion. IN MANAGEMENT, A. I. P. (Ed.) Sustainability in project management. Farnham, Surrey, England, Gower Publishing.

SCUDDER, T. (1973) The Human Ecology of Big Projects: River Basin Development and Resettlement. Annual Review of Anthropology, 2, 45-55.

SHENHAR, A. J. & DVIR, D. (1996) Towards a typological theory of project management. Research Policy, 25, 607-632.

SHENHAR, A. J. & DVIR, D. (2007) Reinventing project management:the diamond approach to successful growth and innovation, Boston, MA, Harvard Business School Press.

SILVIUS, G. (2010) Workshop Report Group 2. IN KNOEPFEL, H. (Ed.) Survival and Sustainbility as Challenges for Projects. Zurich, International Project Management Association.

SILVIUS, G. & SCHIPPER, R. (2012) Sustainability and projects. IN SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R., PLANKO, J., VAN DEN BRINK, J. & KÖHLER, A. (Eds.) Sustainability in project management. Farnham, Surrey. England, Gower Publishing.

SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R. & KÖHLER, A. (2010) Introduction. IN SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R., PLANKO, J., VAN DER BRINK, J. & KÖHLER, A. (Eds.) Sustainability in project management. Farnham, England, Gower Publishing Limited.

SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R. & NEDESKI, S. (2013) Sustainability in project management: Reality bites. PM World Journal. Second Edition ed.

SILVIUS, G., SCHIPPER, R., PLANKO, J., VAN DEN BRINK, J. & KÖHLER, A. (2012) Sustainability in Project Management, Farnham, Surrey. England, Gower Publishing Limited.

SILVIUS, G. & VAN DEN BRINK, J. (2013) Taking responsibility: the integration of sustainability and project management. Association for Project Management.

STILGOE, J. (2013) Forward: Why responsible innovation? IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Responsible innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation in society. Chichester, United Kingdom, Wiley.

STILGOE, J., OWEN, R. & MACNAGHTEN, P. (2013) Developing a framework for responsible innovation. Research Policy, 42, 1568-1580.

VAN DER HOVEN, J. (2013) Value sensitive design and responsible innovation. IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Responsible innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation in society. First ed. Chichester, West Sussex. UK, John Wiley and Sons, Ltd.

VON SCHOMBERG, R. (2013) A vision of responsible research and innovation. IN OWEN, R., BESSANT, J. & HEINTZ, M. (Eds.) Responsible innovation. Managing the responsible emergence of science and innovation. First ed. Chichester, West Sussex. UK, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

WILLARD, B. (2005) The next sustainability wave: Building Boardroom Buy-in, Gabriola Island, New Society Publisher.

ZHANG, X., WU, Y. & SKITMORE, M. (2014) A prototype system dynamic for assessing the sustainability of construction projects International Journal of Project Management, 32, 66-76.

ZWIKAEL, O. & SMYRK, J. (2015) Project governance: Balancing control and trust in dealing with risk. International Journal of Project Management, 33, 852-862.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




______________________________________________________________________________

The Journal of Modern PM (ISSN: 2317-3963) | info@journalmodernpm.com